• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Chatty's Pizzeria

At Chatty's Pizzeria, we celebrate the joy of authentic Italian cuisine in a warm, welcoming environment. Tucked away in Bay Village, this quaint eatery is renowned for its handcrafted pizzas and mouthwatering salads, made from the finest ingredients. Our story is rooted in a passion for food and community, where each dish tells a tale of love and care. From the delightful Cheesy Garlic Bread to our signature Adult Pepperoni pizza, every bite encapsulates a shared experience, whether dining in or enjoying a cozy meal at home. Join us for a delicious journey that keeps the conversation flowing!

Chatty's Pizzeria: Reviews & Ratings

Bernie P.
Bernie P.

Chatty's is definitely worth finding tucked away as it is on the south side of Huntington Beach. Great little Mom & Pop joint with awesome pizza made with care and the best ingredients.

Mary R.
Mary R.

We were pleasantly surprised that they had a special menu yesterday that included Prime Rib and Chicken Marsala. We are trying to avoid carbs and we thoroughly enjoyed the Prime Rib. Service was excellent. My only suggestion is to include these special menu items/days on the website. I only heard about this special menu by word of mouth.

Jordan N.
Jordan N.

It's me again, visiting on another pizza week. Haha! For starters, they've added more seating! They have entire room in the back/side now! We came in on a Wednesday evening at dinner time and there was no wait at all. We were seated at a high top by the kitchen area, which I thought was fun seeing all the employees making pizzas. The employees also seemed happy, like they enjoyed each others company. So that was really nice to see too. I remember loving the cheesy bread so much last time, but it wasn't as good as I remembered. Still good though! And our waitress was nice enough to heat up our sauce for us ! We got the pizza week pizza and salad. Both were delicious. The pizza was way better than I remember it being, which was a wonderful delight! They also have some nice wines on the menu, like Quilt, which is what got. Mmmm Our server was TOP NOTCH. She was very personable and warm. She acted like we've been friends for years! I just really loved her. She really made our experience that much better.

Marjorie C.
Marjorie C.

We stopped in during a trip to see the Rock and roll Hall of Fame, and our hostess greeting us with a warm smile. She's from SC originally, so she asked where we are from (our accents gave us away). We loved chatting with her, and she left us in the hands of an efficient, courteous server who got us taken care of quickly. The pizza was epic! Great crust, cooked perfectly, and excellent salad. Cute place in a great location!

Von M.
Von M.

Best location for pizza in Bay Village. Wonderful atmosphere - just be certain you can tolerate very lively children from babies to pre-teens if you go early. Sweet Heat pizza was excellent. Partners plain NY Style while tasty needed a good mopping of grease toppings. Rey nice service always. The 1.00 charge for rocks in my tequila holds back the fifth star. I thought that only happened in Europe and the desert.

Schyler B.
Schyler B.

I had the lovely experience coming here for the first time during one of the BayArts outdoor concerts, they had nice seating, both indoors and outdoors (front and back of building) we sat outside and got three pizzas which were all very very delicious, I love that the pepperonis were the little ones, the sauce was really good and you can definitely taste the freshness of the dough (it had that really rich pizza oven taste) Our server was very kind, super attentive and when it was just sprinkling not even raining he was very ready to help us move all our stuff to an indoor table. All in all, I wish I had come and tried this pizza earlier. I've lived near this little spot of years and years and I'm so happy to have found a new delicious dining place!

Mehak K.
Mehak K.

Cute place right by Huntington Beach! Came here with a group of 5 Friday early evening right after some beach time, and it was a great way to end the day. We were able to be seated immediately. The cheesy garlic bread starter was delicious and the Mediterranean Veggie pizza and Cacio e Pepe pizzas were solid as well. Would recommend checking this place out if you're in the area!

Hannah W.
Hannah W.

This is my favorite place anymore! I can't get over how kind the servers are every time we have gone, the food is phenomenal, and you can't beat the atmosphere. Great price for a group of us all to eat, and options for all tastes. Good spot for out of towners so you can take them to Huntington right after. Our server was particularly great at explaining the menu and that their "grandma style" is light and not heavy as you may expect from a thick square slice. She was correct in this description and it was so satisfying!

Location

Welcome to Chatty's Pizzeria: a hidden gem nestled in the heart of Bay Village, Ohio, at 28611 Lake Rd. This charming venue offers a culinary experience that seamlessly blends the vibrant flavors of Italy with a warm, inviting atmosphere. Known for its delectable selection of pizza, salads, and Italian specialties, Chatty's Pizzeria aims to satisfy every palate while ensuring a family-friendly environment suitable for gatherings of all sizes.

As you step inside, you'll feel the friendly vibes radiating from both the staff and fellow patrons. This family-run establishment is often lauded for its attentive service—like the warm welcome shared by a hostess or the personable touch of a dedicated server. You can expect a dining experience that leaves you feeling more like part of a community than a mere customer.

  • Culinary Offerings:
    • Pizza: Renowned for its exceptional crust and quality ingredients, the pizza here is a crowd favorite. The Sweet Heat pizza has been praised for its perfect balance of flavors, while other choices, like the Pizza Week special, keep things exciting for repeat visitors.
    • Salads: Complement your meal with a light yet flavorful Grape & Walnut salad. Its signature blend of spring mix, goat cheese, and candied walnuts offers a refreshing counterpoint to the heartier pizza selections.
    • Appetizers: Don't miss out on the Burrata Ball and Cheesy Garlic Bread, particularly when paired with their famous dipping sauce. These starters set the stage for an enjoyable meal ahead.
  • Accessibility and Convenience: Chatty's Pizzeria goes above and beyond to ensure a comfortable dining experience for all. With ADA-compliant facilities and the option for outdoor seating, guests can enjoy their meal regardless of their preferences or needs.
  • Celebrations and Gatherings: With catering services available and a full bar, Chatty's is an excellent venue for private dining or hosting special events. Their attentive service and lively atmosphere make it a popular choice for family dinners or friendly get-togethers.

Among the praises from satisfied customers, one common theme emerges: the delightful experience of good food alongside enthusiastic service. Whether you're enjoying a casual evening or celebrating a special occasion, Chatty's Pizzeria promises to be a food haven that you'll want to revisit time and again. Treat yourself to their culinary creations, and you may just find your next favorite pizza place right here in Bay Village.

To join in on this exceptional dining experience, simply dial (440) 471-4485 to place an order for takeout or check out their menu online—where you’ll find QR codes for easy access. Remember, at Chatty's Pizzeria, you'll not only savor great food but also become a part of a community that loves good times and great pies!